فقه استاد شب زنده دار7/8

[محمد اشعری]

خارج فقه استاد شب زنده دار
بحث در و انکر المنکر بیدک و لسانک
اشکال این شد که مرحوم ابن طاووس فرموده بین نقل کلینی,و دیگران تفاوتروجود دارد و ما حجت اجمالی پیدا میکنیم که برخی فقرات حجت نمیشوند یا به جهت تعارض انها باهم یاوبه جهت دوران بین نقصان و زیاده لذا تمسک محل اشکال است
الاعتبار نویسنده معروف به الشجری در این کتاب نسخه های دیگر امده و در ان نسخه این فقره امده است
بنابرین این اشکال دوم بعد از این فحص ممکن است کسی ان را وارد نداند مگر اینکه بگوییم صاحب این کتاب که زیدی هم هست استناد این روایات به نحو ارسال است مگر اینکه به نحو شخصی اطمینان به تطابق پیدا کند.
اشکال سوم
واو به معنای جمع بین این دو مرتبه باشد( باید معا اتیان شوند) این بیان معرض عنه اصحاب است
جواب
گاهی واو به معنای او میاید
واو در مواردی ظهور در جمع دارد که با یکی از انها ممکن است مصلحت مورد نظر استیفا نشود ولی در جاییک ه یکی از متعاطفین مصلحت حاصل میشود مثل اینکه بگویند از یکی از دو در خارج شوید منظور خروج از از هرکزام که باشد,تفاوتی نمیکنید
اینکه هرکدام از متعاطفین اثر را مترتب میکند قرینه میشود که مولا در تمام موارد امربهمعروف جمع بین موارد را نمیخواهد البته در مواردی که غرض با یکی از انها حاصل نمیشود جمع لازم است
اشکال
قبلا گفتیم شیخ طوسی فرمودند الظاهر من شیوخنا الامامیه
که انکار به ید مختص من له اذن الام است ارتکاز امامیه و شیخ امامیه ان است که ضرب مختص به همه نیست
شهید صدر: در این جور مواقع عقلا اصالت عدم قرینه جاری نمیکنند
اون قرینیه سیاقیه که قبلا گفتیم که تمام فقرات عمومی است و خاص یک فرد نیست معارضه میکند با این قرینه ارتکازی که ضرب برای عموم افراد نیست
نتیجه این میشود که یا این فقره مختص فرد خاص است یا به اجمال می انجامد و در این جا فتوا سخت است یا باید علی نحو الاشکال یا با ارجاع به دیگران احتیاط کرد
طایفه ثالثه و رابعه برای فردا انشالله

[سید صالح صالحی]

با عرض سلام
وجه اینکه این علم اجمالی چگونه جلوی استدلال به این روایت می گیرد، نفرمودید (ذکرش بهتر بود)
کمی توضیح بیشتر در اینکه: چگونه از کلام مرحوم شیخ ارتکاز متشرعه را فهمیدیم و اینکه چرا در چنین مواردی اصاله عدم قرینه جاری نیست، بهتر بود.

[FrankJScott]

For the man asking about menang togel online, idn live casino, game slot terbaru, apa game slot, agen casino online, agen judi online terpercaya, situs slot online terpercaya, dewa togel online, permainan slot asli, situs yang bisa deposit pulsa, I highly recommend this updated tajir4d link alternatif link or play togel, situs web slot terpercaya, situs agen slot, game slot online resmi, live judi slot, da slot, situs joker gaming, deposit togel, game slot uang asli, slot slot games, on top of this such a good point for tajir4d link alternatif info and don't forget game online pulsa, game slot tembak ikan, bandar togel slot online, game slot live, togel 4d slot login, slot togel, situs togel dan slot terbesar, situs live game, slot online aplikasi, slot judi togel, alongside all this excellent tajir4d advice which is also great. Also, have a look at this high rated tajir4d site and don't forget 4d slot login, situs resmi togel dan slot, situs judi online casino, situs casino online, game terbaru saat ini, situs online judi, situs pulsa slot, live judi slot, situs situs slot online, togel situs online, on top of this had me going on tajir4d link alternatif link together with slot judi adalah, deposit pulsa online, judi togel online terpercaya, slot judi slot, situs judi on, moved here for together with game online pulsa, bandar judi terbesar di indonesia, cara main slot game, slot adalah permainan, slot uang asli, for good measure. Check more @ Updated TAJIR4D Tips 245796a

[FrankJScott]

For the person talking about facial list, best juvederm lip filler, best laser treatment for scars on face, best rf microneedling treatment, face tightening facial, lip filler in, face filler injections, microneedling facial, best lip filler, best pdo threads, I highly suggest this updated pigmentation treatment Sarasota tips or cosmetic facial rejuvenation, rf microneedling body, medical spa aesthetics, lifting threads for face, plasma facial rejuvenation, skin care peels, face tightening treatment, microneedling skin treatment, best facial to rejuvenate skin, microneedling for tightening skin, which is worth considering with this his explanation for laser treatment near me details alongside all filler rha, laser skin tightening, sarasota microneedling, renuva injections, p injections, prp vampire treatment, lifting facial treatment, skin tightening with microneedling, rf microneedling skin tightening, co2 skin treatment, as well as this description about pigmentation treatment Sarasota details which is also great. Also, have a look at this high rated Best laser treatment Sarasota forum together with cosmetic peels, environ cool peel facial, skin care medical spa, facial co2, skin rejuvenation injections, lip procedures, laser lift, skin care fillers, cool peel facial, rf laser face, alongside all this top rated Best laser treatment Sarasota tips on top of best laser skin tightening, laser wrinkle, facials florida, prp hair treatment florida, rf body treatment, our site on not forgetting sites such as regenerative aesthetics, pdo lift, fibroblast skin tightening treatment, led therapy, derma prp, for good measure. Check more @ Useful TAJIR4D Site c675766

[FrankJScott]

To the lady inquiring about ai and stocks, investment ai software, stock market data analysis, ai companies with stock, stock research software, ai stocks us, nasdaq ai companies, number one ai stock, best stock ai software, the best ai stocks to invest in, I highly recommend this awesome AI stock predictions platform blog or artificial intelligence for investment, ai stock prediction, about stock investment, stock market prediction app, analytics stocks, stock market study, ai trading account, best stock reports, stock picks free, best ai stocks, as well as this continue for AI stock picker analysis site not forgetting sites such as ai for stock market prediction, software that tells you when to buy and sell stocks, ai for share trading, ai stock index, best app for analyzing stocks, stock market tools software, best stock prediction website free, ai trading prediction, stock market prediction software, stocks and investing, as well as this at bing about AI stock investing analysis url which is also great. Also, have a look at this more tips here about AI stock investing analysis forum not to mention stock analysis websites free, ai market trading, artificial intelligence stock market prediction software, best stock research software, ai software stocks, best free stock information websites, stock gpt, best websites for the stock market, best free stock forecast website, best ai stock trading app, as well as this great AI stock investing analysis advice not forgetting sites such as ai companies stock, stock market ai, ai for stock investing, ai software companies stock, stock analysis online free, her response for and don't forget best artificial intelligence stocks to buy now, stock trading, best stock market analysis app, stock market technical analysis, stock analysis programs, for good measure. Check more @ Cool Daftar Akun Judi Info 7cf14a5

[FrankJScott]

In reply to the man talking about nomor togel sidney hari ini, slot spadegaming, live draw sgp terpercaya, jitu togel login, situs togel terbesar dan terpercaya di indonesia, situs online judi, keluaran togel lengkap, togel 4d slot, web judi terpercaya, website slot terbaik, I highly recommend this discover more on tajir4d login link or slot spadegaming rtp tertinggi, daftar angka keluar hongkong, angka keluar sgp live draw, situs terbaik judi slot, bandar judi di indonesia, situs game judi online, bandar judi online, slot slot online, pasaran togel slot, play pragmatic slot, which is worth considering with this top asian2bet login advice as well as togel sdy sgp hk, daftar game slot online terpercaya, data angka keluar hk, slot online joker123, slot casino indonesia, hasil angka keluar sgp, bandar togel online terbesar dan terpercaya, agen togel live 4d, 10 situs judi slot online terpercaya, main judi slot online, not to mention this description about asian2bet tips which is also great. Also, have a look at this weblink about tajir4d forum on top of bermain slot adalah, angka keluar togel sgp hari ini, permainan slot mudah menang, bisa bermain, bandar togel online terbesar, situs slot pg soft terbaik, slot toto online, bocoran togel sdy hari ini, data keluaran sgp hari ini, situs judi slot online 4d, not to mention this related site on tajir4d advice alongside all prediksi angka togel sgp hari ini, apa judi slot, angka keluaran sgp, situs slot judi online, pengeluaran togel hk hari ini, continued for not forgetting sites such as situs togel slot terpercaya, slot games slot, beberapa permainan, game yang lain, daftar judi togel online, for good measure. Check more @ Top AI Stock Picking Platform Tips f73_065

[FrankJScott]

To the guy asking about togel 4d slot, login akun togel, game slot gampang menang, data togel hongkong, agen togel terlengkap, situs slot pg soft, bandar judi di indonesia, slot judi terpercaya, slot mudah jackpot, jenis game slot online, I highly suggest this my review here for asian2bet login link or data togel singapore, situs judi casino online terpercaya, link togel singapore, situs judi slot mudah menang, link akun togel, permainan casino online, judi slot mudah menang, link slot online, situs slot terbesar indonesia, prediksi togel sgp, which is worth considering with this awesome asian2bet login details which is worth considering with kami slot link alternatif, keluaran togel sydney hari ini, data togel sgp, slot uang asli, game terbaru slot, link slot judi terpercaya, judi slot yang gampang menang, slot terbaik pg soft, akun judi slot, casino pg soft, alongside all this read what he said on tajir4d login tips which is also great. Also, have a look at this more hints about asian2bet info and don't forget situs resmi judi slot online, game slot terbaik uang asli, link situs togel terpercaya, slot pragmatic play, link situs slot terpercaya, togel sidney togel sidney, game slot pg soft mudah menang, menang judi slot link alternatif, jenis permainan casino, permainan yang bisa, bearing in mind this i thought about this on asian2bet forum on top of angka keluar sgp tercepat, taruhan slot, slot soft, data togel singapore 2022, pengeluaran togel singapura, learn more here for alongside all link slot yang mudah menang, bocoran sgp togel hari ini angka jitu, situs togel terpercaya indonesia, slot uang asli, link game slot online terbaik, for good measure. Check more @ Awesome Asian2bet Login Website 14a581c