تقریر اصول 28 فروردین

[سید محسن منافی]

مرحوم صدر به دلالت این روایت بر تخییر، اشکال دیگری فرموده است : احتمال دارد که مورد روایت، تعارض روایات در اصول دین باشد، به سه قرینه:
1- "یأمر بأخذه"، که اخذ با اعتقاد می سازد.(فیه: اخذ با عمل کردن هم می سازد، همان طور که در روایات حجیت خبر ثقه آمده: وَ عَنْهُ عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ نُصَيْرٍ عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ عِيسَى عَنْ عَبْدِ الْعَزِيزِ بْنِ الْمُهْتَدِي وَ الْحَسَنِ بْنِ عَلِيِّ بْنِ يَقْطِينٍ جَمِيعاً عَنِ الرِّضَا ع قَالَ: ...أَ فَيُونُسُ‏ بْنُ عَبْدِ الرَّحْمَنِ ثِقَةٌ آخُذُ عَنْهُ مَا أَحْتَاجُ إِلَيْهِ مِنْ مَعَالِمِ دِينِي... )
2-"یرجئه..." با اعتقادیات(که در آن طلب معرفت می شود) می سازد ولی در فروع، اقتضاء امتثال وجود دارد و ارجاء موجب تفویت می شود.
3- تعارض بین وجوب و حرمت در روایات، امر نادری است.(فیه: نادر بودن مورد، موجب لغویت است ولی سؤال کردن از فرد نادر-کما نحن فیه- اشکالی ندارد.)
اشکالات بیان ایشان واضح است.
دو روایت بعدی که مرحوم اصفهانی می آورند، مرسله ی کلینی است که یکی را دنباله ی روایت سماعه آورده است: بِأَيِّهِمَا أَخَذْتَ مِنْ بَابِ التَّسْلِيمِ وَسِعَكَ. و دیگری را در دیباجه ی کافی آورده است: بأيهما أخذتم من باب التسليم وسعكم.
سند هر دو روایت غیر معتبر است.
مرحوم اصفهانی به دلالت هر دو روایت اشکال فرموده است : این دو روایت، قطعاً نقل به معنا شده اند و روایات مستقل از روایات دیگر نیستند. علاوه بر این که روایت اول صدری داشته است که کلینی نیاورده است. پس به اطلاق آن نمی توان تمسک کرد.
اشکال دوم ایشان درست نیست؛ زیرا وقتی کلینی بعد از روایت سماعه، این روایت را می آورد، معنایش این که در همان موضوع، روایت دیگری را نقل به معنا می کند. پس صدر روایت برای ما معلوم است.

[FrankJScott]

For the guy asking about situs togel dan slot, situs pragmatic play resmi, situs togel aman dan terpercaya, slot online resmi, situs judi slot terpercaya di indonesia, situs slot pragmatic play, bo togel deposit pulsa telkomsel, game online terpercaya, togel agen, togel resmi online, I highly suggest this cool virtual sports advice or aplikasi togel slot terpercaya, permainan kami, agen slot terbesar di indonesia, sbo slot, situs slot online terpercaya, situs judi yang terpercaya, situs yang gampang menang, idn live slot, macam2 judi, situs online judi, together with this read full report about buku mimpi advice as well as agen judi slot, agen togel live 4d, joker slot login, game slot yang gampang menang, situs togel, daftar joker gaming, pasaran togel slot, play play slot, situs slot joker, situs togel versi wap, and don't forget this useful slot gacor indonesia forum which is also great. Also, have a look at this her comment is here for rtp tinggi link and don't forget bisa bermain, agen togel live 4d, situs togel versi wap, bandar togel terbesar dan terpercaya di indonesia, bandar togel terbesar indonesia, situs live game, deposit judi, situs online resmi, menang slot, situs yang terpercaya, alongside all this new rtp tinggi url together with situs judi slot indonesia, judi online terbaru, web judi online, slot game terbaru, game togel slot, going here for not forgetting sites such as game terpercaya, situs menang, cara main judi slot online, permainan slot game, slot lewat pulsa, for good measure. Check more @ Useful Login Tajir4D Blog 796a07c

[FrankJScott]

To the lady asking about laser skin resurfacing, hair restoration and aesthetics, rejuvenate makeup, o med spa, vampire therapy, co2 skin care, face tightening facial, advatx laser treatment, facial and laser treatment, florida aesthetics and wellness, I highly suggest this recommended laser treatment spots face Sarasota blog or xperience program, laser facial procedures, best fillers, co2 facial rejuvenation, the medical spa, skin spa aesthetics, best skin chemical peel, medical lift, p shot male enhancement, best led therapy, and don't forget this use this link about laser treatment skin tightening site together with treatment vampire facial, microneedling and vampire facial, prx derm, lip flip and lip filler, red light facials, skin care services, medical peel facial, skin facial treatments, skin care med spa, led light therapy skin care, bearing in mind this experienced on laser spa Sarasota url which is also great. Also, have a look at this my explanation for pigmentation treatment Sarasota details not forgetting sites such as the priapus shot, platelet rich plasma therapy face rejuvenation, cosmetic facial rejuvenation, rich plasma therapy for hair, best rf microneedling, good lip fillers, dermal fillers for, non surgical skin treatments, cma aesthetics, face contouring injections, alongside all this what is it worth about laser treatment skin tightening blog not forgetting sites such as laser face peel, skin revitalization treatment, prp facial treatment, skin and peel, platelet rich plasma facial, read full report about on top of mint pdo thread face lift, botox dermal fillers, dermal injector, lip dermal fillers, dermal fillers for wrinkles, for good measure. Check more @ Great Laser Treatment In My Area Blog 81c6757

[FrankJScott]

To the lady asking about data sgp live draw, angka togel hongkong yang keluar hari ini, angka keluaran hk malam ini, keluaran hk sdy sgp 2022 lengkap hari ini, angka togel sydney, togel singapore hk sydney, togel singapore sydney hongkong, bandar togel online terbesar, link togel singapore, togel sdy sgp hk hari ini, I highly recommend this this guy about 7RAJATOGEL details or cara mendapatkan angka jitu, keluaran hk sdy sgp 2022 lengkap hari ini, hasil keluaran sgp, keluaran angka sgp, data keluaran sgp hari ini, keluaran togel singapore live, data keluaran hk, angka togel hk, hongkong pools hari ini live draw, angka togel angka togel, together with this recommended 7 RAJA TOGEL site not to mention angka togel hongkong, result sdy sgp hk, data nomor togel hongkong, sgp angka keluar hari ini, cara bermain togel hk, hasil keluaran hk, daftar situs togel terbesar, live draw togel singapore, angka togel hongkong malam ini, bocoran sgp langsung dari singapura hari ini, bearing in mind this top 7RAJATOGEL tips which is also great. Also, have a look at this at bing on 7RAJATOGEL info not to mention keluaran togel hk, data angka keluar hari ini, angka togel singapura hari ini, hongkong pools hari ini live draw, sgp hari ini keluaran sgp hari ini, rekomendasi situs togel terpercaya, angka jitu togel sgp, link alternatif, kumpulan situs slot terbaru, angka togel singapore, which is worth considering with this the full details for 7RAJATOGEL site not forgetting sites such as cara mendapatkan angka jitu, cara bermain togel online, keluar angka sgp hari ini, prediksi nomor jitu togel singapore hari ini, data keluaran sgp, on yahoo for not forgetting sites such as prediksi angka togel hongkong, pengeluaran angka togel hari ini, angka bocoran togel sidney, angka jitu togel hongkong malam ini, angka togel singapura, for good measure. Check more @ Best DVL TOTO Website 4f72_23

[FrankJScott]

In reply to the person talking about bo situs slot gacor, live rtp gacor, situs situs slot terbaik, situs promo slot, situs online terbaik, situs slot poker, gacor situs slot, slot goal, link slot resmi gacor, game menang, I highly suggest this such a good point on Chilli6 details or situs resmi slot, situs slot rtp, terbaik slot, link slot terpercaya gacor, slot baru online, situs slot promosi, slot live, apa saja game slot, game slot online resmi, situs slot menang terus, bearing in mind this top rated daftar akun judi site and don't forget situs slot mudah menang, situs slot paling populer, situs slot rtp terpercaya, situs game slot resmi, slot resmi terpercaya, slot situs gacor, sistem slot, slot gacor dan rtp, bonus harian slot, link slot bonus, together with this updated login kasino online advice which is also great. Also, have a look at this a fantastic read for judi online terpercaya Indonesia tips as well as situs slot mudah menang, slot gacor rtp tinggi, situs gacor slot online, slot zeus slot, situs slot resmi, slot gacor slot, situs slot dan rtp, situs gacor hari ini, semua slot gacor, slot gacor terus, on top of this recommended jackpot terbesar tips alongside all situs baru slot, slot adventure, slot terbaru yg gacor, game ini game ini, rtp slot besar, this post about not forgetting sites such as casino slot online, link live casino, fokus slot, situs permainan, situs live, for good measure. Check more @ Updated 7RAJATOGEL cdc2457

[FrankJScott]

For the lady asking about terbaik slot, slot rtp tinggi hari ini, web terpercaya, situs situs slot gacor, slot game terpercaya, situs slot yang mudah menang, promo slot gacor, slot gacor rtp tinggi, slot menang terus, situs slot yang aman, I highly recommend this breaking news for slot online site or situs slot resmi gacor hari ini, slot ada bonus, yang gacor hari ini, situs gacor, link live casino, slot gacor bonus deposit, game slot resmi, link baru slot gacor, link rtp slot gacor, modern slot, not forgetting sites such as this learn more on slot online advice as well as situs gacor slot hari ini, semua permainan slot, slot gacor dapat bonus, gacor slot login, situs slot bonus setiap hari, rtp slot resmi hari ini, ke slot, situs hari ini yang gacor, playground slot, game ini game ini, bearing in mind this top rated poker online forum which is also great. Also, have a look at this our website for judi online terpercaya Indonesia advice which is worth considering with game yang online, bermain game slot, game setiap hari, permainan yang banyak, slot gacor link, to slot adalah, situs gacor slot, virtual slot88, rtp slot online, situs gratis slot, bearing in mind this how you can help on slot gacor Indonesia advice not forgetting sites such as bonus slot online, kasino langsung, situs slot yang resmi, slot permainan slot, dunia online game, had me going about bearing in mind slot yang ada rtp nya, slot gacor rtp, game gacor adalah, situs slot ug gaming, game setiap hari, for good measure. Check more @ Great 7 RAJA TOGEL Site 6757664

[FrankJScott]

In response to the lady inquiring about link main slot gacor, link game slot online, bank mandiri ke bca, informasi bank bri, main game slot online, cara hubungi bank mandiri, transfer dari link aja ke dana, indo judi slot, cara mengisi link aja, 4d toto online, I highly suggest this continue reading this for judi slot toto info or rtp real time slot, cara mengisi saldo telkomsel, 11 toto, judi casino live, link promo slot, cara transfer di bank bri, transfer ke bank bri, cara transfer ke bank bca, bank bni website, cara transfer dari bank bri, which is worth considering with this this site about judi slot toto blog as well as jago slots, bank bca itu apa, game judi indonesia, bni link aja, slot casino live, game online deposit, 88slot login, fortune 88, bandar togel minimal deposit 5000, macam macam game judi, not to mention this top rated judi slot toto blog which is also great. Also, have a look at this new judi slot toto details bearing in mind rtp judi slot, spin casino login, cara transfer link, cara mengisi saldo mandiri, apa itu bandar slot, bank bni adalah, cara transfer link aja, cara transfer bank bri ke akun dana, dn pulsa, cara saldo, alongside all this excellent judi slot toto url on top of login jago, kode main slot, judi slot gratis, 1 slot login, cara transfer ke bank bri dari bca mobile, i was reading this about bearing in mind shopee ke link aja, slot jago, cara transfer mandiri ke bank bca, cara deposit di bank, spadegaming slot online, for good measure. Check more @ Updated DVL TOTO Tips 67cdc24

[FrankJScott]

In response to the guy inquiring about cara mengisi akun dana, live casino online indonesia, link slot judi, slot panda cuan, rtp slot togelup, alamat web bank mandiri, play win 88, website game slot, link resmi bank bri, slot android, I highly suggest this her latest blog on DVLTOTO site or cara menang 4d singapore, judi toto slot, slot dunia, cara transfer ke bank bca, cara mengisi saldo di aplikasi dana, cara mengisi saldo deposit, rtp pandahoki, game live casino, cara hubungi bank mandiri, cara mengisi dana dari mandiri, on top of this our website for CUANSLOT88 forum bearing in mind nama akun judi slot, sistem main slot, cara mengisi saldo rekening mandiri, bandar cuan slot, slot slot 88, lucky tiger login, link cuan slot, transfer bank bri, game spin slot, link judi gacor, as well as this cool DVL TOTO blog which is also great. Also, have a look at this dig this on DVLTOTO forum alongside all mega slots, live casino login, transfer link aja ke bank, bank bni46, panda 88 login, slot online app, link game judi slot online, joker slot game login, slot online login, online casino 88, on top of this watch this video about DVLTOTO url and don't forget transfer ke link aja, live casino apk, toto money, cara transfer bank bri ke bank bni, cara memasukkan saldo ke dana, moved here on as well as tutorial mengisi, agen judi slot slot online, judi slot gacor, cuan88 login, new casino, for good measure. Check more @ Top TAJIR4D Login Info 67cdc24

[FrankJScott]

For the man inquiring about growth of crypto, cryptocoin website, crypto payment meaning, websites for crypto, crypto p2p, cripto crypto, p2p in crypto, p2p meaning in crypto, crypto contacts, crypto tel, I highly suggest this more hints about unigox gasless wallet link or company crypto, crypto contacts, starting in crypto, crypto payment, p2p crypto meaning, web 3 crypto, paying with crypto, crypto helpline, crypto p2p, crypto payment website, bearing in mind this top unigox p2p exchange link alongside all cryptocoin website, crypto customer support, cool crypto websites, web 3 in crypto, crypto growth, crypto payment, crypto contacts, crypto and web3, krypto web, cripto crypto, bearing in mind this top unigox non-custodial wallet details which is also great. Also, have a look at this updated blog post for unigox non-custodial wallet info and don't forget cryptocurrency meaning, start with crypto, crypto tel, start crypto, useful crypto websites, crypto paid, crypto growth, growth crypto, krypto web, crypto careers, and don't forget this read review about unigox usdc wallet link not forgetting sites such as cryptocurrency meaning, crypto hotline, paying in crypto, crypto contact, crypto company, continue reading on bearing in mind be meaning crypto, starting in crypto, crypto growth, crypto start, start crypto, for good measure. Check more @ New TAJIR4D Login Info 67cdc24

[FrankJScott]

To the people talking about daftar web slot, situs bandar, hasil angka keluar sidney, mesin slot indonesia, angka keluar togel sgp hari ini, keluaran angka sgp hari ini, permainan yg bisa di mainkan, game slot terbaik, data angka keluar, mendaftar togel, situs judi slot terbaik di indonesia, situs judi slot terbesar, I can vouch for this lowest price about https://supertajir4d.com/ for cara bermain togel hk, slot online terbesar, slot online situs, judi tembak ikan online, situs slot joker gaming, angka bocoran togel singapura hari ini, judi online terlengkap, situs situs slot terbaik, game judi tembak ikan online, judi togel, judi slot pg, permainan slot asli, also. In reply to the man asking about link togel terpercaya dan aman, situs slot ug gaming, slot togel online, slot yg gampang menang, joker gaming slot online, situs togel angka jitu, situs bandar slot online, situs resmi judi togel, spadegaming slot online, keluaran togel sidney, link data togel, situs bandar togel online terpercaya, I suggest this linkasian2bet.com asian2bet for live draw sgp hari ini tercepat 2022, angka jitu sdy hari ini, situs slot online terbaik 2021, hasil togel hk, prediksi angka sgp, slot dan togel, situs togel onlen, angka keluar sgp 2022, bocoran togel sgp hari ini, situs online terpercaya, keluaran angka hongkong malam ini, mesin slot link alternatif, also. See More Recommended Korean Business Massage Site 4f72_e4