29 بهمن

بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم
دوشنبه 29 بهمن ماه _ فقه استاد قائنی-قسامه

بحث در اشتراط لوث در مشروعیت قسامه
صحیحه زراره دلالتش روشن و بقیه روایات دلالت روشنی نداشت.

روایت پنجم
صاحب جواهر
وَ عَنْهُ عَنْ هَارُونَ بْنِ مُسْلِمٍ عَنْ مَسْعَدَةَ بْنِ زِيَادٍ عَنْ جَعْفَرٍ ع قَالَ: كَانَ أَبِي رَضِيَ اللَّهُ عَنْهُ إِذَا لَمْ يُقِمِ الْقَوْمُ الْمُدَّعُونَ- الْبَيِّنَةَ عَلَى قَتْلِ قَتِيلِهِمْ- وَ لَمْ يُقْسِمُوا بِأَنَّ الْمُتَّهَمِينَ قَتَلُوهُ- حَلَّفَ الْمُتَّهَمِينَ بِالْقَتْلِ خَمْسِينَ يَمِيناً بِاللَّهِ- مَا قَتَلْنَاهُ وَ لَا عَلِمْنَا لَهُ قَاتِلًا- ثُمَّ يُؤَدِّي الدِّيَةَ إِلَى أَوْلِيَاءِ الْقَتِيلِ- ذَلِكَ إِذَا قُتِلَ فِي حَيٍّ وَاحِدٍ- فَأَمَّا إِذَا قُتِلَ فِي عَسْكَرٍ أَوْ سُوقِ مَدِينَةٍ- فَدِيَتُهُ تُدْفَعُ إِلَى أَوْلِيَائِهِ مِنْ بَيْتِ الْمَالِ.(وسائل الشيعة، ج‌29، ص:153)
فعل یودَّی الدیه باید معلوم باشد نه مجهول ، زیرا مورد روایت شخص متهم متعدد فرض شد و اگر قراربود خودشان پرداخت کنند باید گفته میشد یودُّوا
روایت میگوید مقتول اگر در حی باشد، مردم آن حی باید دیه را بپردازند اما اگر در مرکز شهر باشد باید از بیت المال پرداخت شود.
از جهت تفصیل بین قتیل حی و غیر حی میتوان گفت لوث شرط است زیرا اگر لوث نباشد تفصیل جا ندارد و در نهایت میفرمایند تفصیل بخاطر محل پرداخت دیه است نه لوث
مراد روایت حصر قسامه در این فرض نیست و نمیتواند شرط لوث باشد مگر اینکه گفته شود مفروض روایت لوث است ولذا گویا اعتبار و اشتراط لوث در روایت مفروغ است اما به نظر ما اینکه مفروغیت اعتبار را برساند ، خیلی روشن نیست.

تا اینجا شرط بودن لوث مشخص شد.
مرحوم اردبیلی
ایشان که در کل روایات تشکیک کرده اند و دلالتشان را بر اشتراط نپذیرفته اند میفرمایند قضیه را باید با اجماع درست کرد.
صاحب ریاض
لوث شرط است زیرا در اینجا از موارد شک در حجیت است . و اطلاقی هم بر حجیت قسامه نداریم و این روایات در مقام بیان اصل مشروعیت قسامه است اما اطلاق ندارد.سر آن این است که روایات قسامه دو طایفه است.یک طایفه روایات خیبر و طایفه دیگر دو یا سه روایتی است که ان الله حکم فی دمائکم
اما روایت مشتمل بر قضیه خیبر و حکم به قسامه : آنها اطلاق ندارد و میگوید در آن قضیه قسامه ثابت است و در انجا اتهام مفروض بود و اگر اتهام مفروض نبودنمیتوان تعدی کرد مگر به الغاء خصوصیت که این هم معلوم نیست.
اما طایفه دوم : مفاد این است که بدانید میزان باب دماء فرق دارد.اما اینکه کجا و با چه شرائطی بینه بر عهده مدعی علیه است و آیا مطلقاست ؛ این را نمی رساند و میخواهد بگوید فکر نکنید حجت بر قصاص منحصر در بینه است.ولذا اطلاقی بر حجیت قسامه در غیر لوث نداریم.

ان شئت فقل : اگر دلیل از حیثی در مقام بیان بود و از حیثیت دیگری نمیدانیم ، اصلی که بیان کند که در مقام بیان بوده وجود ندارد. اصاله الاطلاق هم کارایی ندارد. مجرای اصاله الاطلاق، شک در مقام بیان بودن است، مثلا احل البیع. در این مثال نمیدانیم آیا اجمال گویی است یا نه ، اصل جاری میشود. اما اگر کلام از حیثی حتما در مقام بیان است اما از حیثی نه ، نمیتوان به اصلاله الاطلاق تمسک کرد.
استاد : انکار اطلاق توسط صاحب ریاض حرف بعیدی نیست. اگر از این هم گذشتیم و گفتیم اطلاق وجود دارد باز میگوییم لوث شرط است زیرا اشتراط لوث از مشهورات بین کل المسلمین است و این حاکی از مفروغیت آن در اذهان مسلمین است به نحوی که اگر امام میخواستند اطلاق را اتکالا بر ان قید لوث بفهمانند جا داشت و از قبیل قرینه متصلی است که مانع شکل گیری اطلاق میشود.

سلام علیکم
نکاتی در فایل ضمیمه تذکر داده شد

For the man talking about best stock trading robot, ai and day trading, ai stock futures, ai chat gpt stock, best ai investing apps, stock price for ai, ai trading bot stocks, fundamentals of stock trading, best stock market analysis tools, free stock analysis, I highly recommend this view website about AI stock investing analysis advice or ai stock rating, best ai stocks for long term, best stocks for ai, artificial intelligence and investing, chat gpt stock prediction, best stock picker, ai for stock picking, best platform for stock analysis, otc ai stocks, best free stock analysis app, and don't forget this high rated AI stock picker platform forum as well as best website for stock forecast, stock gpt, openai stock buy, stock price prediction software, ai investment companies, best stock analysis, best stock recommendations app, investing analysis, website to analyze stocks, ai publicly traded companies, on top of this best AI stock trading platform blog which is also great. Also, have a look at this top rated AI stock investing analysis details not to mention ai top stocks, best ai tech stocks, ai us stock, best artificial intelligence stocks to buy now, stock picking software reviews, stock market ai bot, ai company share price, investment for stock market, stock research tool, us stock analysis website, which is worth considering with this top AI stock trading analysis advice on top of stock prediction using ai, good ai stocks to buy, best stock trading ai, day trading ai, ai share companies, cool training about bearing in mind ai to trade stocks, stock trading ai software, ai app for stock market, best free stock market websites, ai stock advisor, for good measure. Check more @ Excellent Login Tajir4D Info 4a581c6

In response to the person asking about website togel online, judi online terbaik, slot togel deposit pulsa, situs 24 jam, joker play slot, slot situs terpercaya, masuk game slot online, login joker slot, slot pragmatic adalah, main casino online, I highly suggest this how you can help on Tajir4D site or judi slot asli, judi online game, hk slot online, link togel online terpercaya, bandar togel online terbesar dan terpercaya, slot situs terpercaya, siap slot login, idn slot pragmatic, permainan judi togel, joker slot online, together with this go here on TAJIR4D Login advice not forgetting sites such as slot judi, situs togel slot terpercaya, situs judi slot paling lengkap, game slot live, game slot web, agen togel onlen, semua situs judi slot, kami slot, aplikasi judi slot, slot online pulsa, alongside all this link for TAJIR4D Login link which is also great. Also, have a look at this breaking news for TAJIR4D Login advice on top of main game slot online, bermain slot online, situs slot bisa deposit pulsa, situs slot online, situs deposit pulsa telkomsel, permainan slot online, web judi togel, aplikasi judi slot, situs togel online terpercaya di indonesia, situs bandar togel terbesar, not forgetting sites such as this updated Tajir4D info on top of cara main game slot online, deposit via pulsa telkomsel, situs main slot terpercaya, judi slot tembak ikan, game mudah menang, discover more for alongside all slot togel deposit pulsa, bermain judi online, bandar togel terbaik di indonesia, togel play, slot pragmatic play, for good measure. Check more @ Excellent Laser Treatment Results Tips 1c67576

To the people inquiring about popular tropical aquarium fish, freshwater aquarium fish store, purple freshwater aquarium fish, hardiest freshwater aquarium fish, live aquarium fish, tropical fish online store, live freshwater fish free shipping, fresh water snail, long freshwater aquarium fish, tropical fish tank for beginners, tropical fish species for tank, aquarium fish uk, tropical water fish, cherry shrimp for sale near me, snails for freshwater tank, best freshwater aquarium fish for beginners, mail order live fish, live aquarium snails for sale, best mix of fish for freshwater aquarium, snails from aquarium plants, I suggest this a fantastic read for amano shrimp advice for colorful fish, exoctic fish for sale, benefit of snails in aquarium, all in one shrimp tank, tropical fish for beginners, tropical shrimp for sale near me, nice fish for aquarium, pretty fish freshwater, colourful fish for fish tank, online fish store, various aquarium fish, fresh water aquarium snails, red freshwater aquarium fish, live water fish, red cherry shrimp buy, buy nerite snails uk, best place to buy live fish online, tropical fish for home tank, fish with shrimp, buy live tropical fish, live tropical freshwater fish, long freshwater aquarium fish, shrimp with fish, also. See More Useful 7 RAJA TOGEL Info 96a07cf

For the guy inquiring about slot gameplay, game slot rtp, ufc slot, situs terbaru slot online, to adalah slot, situs slot yang gampang menang, gameplay slot, link game slot terpercaya, situs mainan, pemain gacor, I highly suggest this recommended site about kasino online link or slot terpercaya dan gacor, slot online slot, situs slot play, game slot yang gacor hari ini, live score slot, permainan yang bisa di, hari ini slot gacor, slot rtp tinggi hari ini, rtp terbaik slot, slot gacor situs, and don't forget this view website about RTP tinggi details not forgetting sites such as slot online promo, slot bonus gacor, situs bonus deposit, resmi slot, situs slot live, situs slot gacor rtp tinggi, game slot menang besar, game slot dengan kemenangan besar, game slot online resmi, situs slot ternama, not forgetting sites such as this visit website on Chilli6 forum which is also great. Also, have a look at this top virtual sports tips not forgetting sites such as slot online gacor, slot rtp, khusus slot, slot terpercaya gacor hari ini, semua situs slot online, situs slot yang ada hacksaw gaming, slot gacor abis, situs web slot gacor, slot gacor baru, info permainan slot gacor hari ini, on top of this new slot gacor Indonesia tips which is worth considering with game slot live, slot sistem, situs situs slot gacor, situs yang gacor, slot gacor online, his explanation for as well as permainan live casino, casino slot online, slot situs resmi, rtp slot besar hari ini, situs terbaru slot gacor, for good measure. Check more @ High Rated 7 RAJA TOGEL Blog 67cdc24

한국 최고의 카지노 사이트를 찾고 있다면 바카라사이트 을 위한 바카라사이트 순위, 카지노커뮤니티, 한국 카지노사이트, 실시간카지노사이트, 카지노커뮤니티, 카지노커뮤니티, 한국 카지노사이트, 바카라사이트 추천, 카지노사이트 모음, 카지노사이트 모음, 바카라사이트 모음, 카지노사이트, 온라인카지노, 바카라사이트 추천 그리고 카지노사이트 순위, 카지노사이트 순위, 온라인카지노.

To the lady talking about tesla model y getting started, tesla 3 y, buy a new tesla model y, tesla model y base model, model 3 cover, tesla model y top accessories, model s accessories, accessories for tesla y, tesla model y model 3, model 3 and s, I highly recommend this best Tesla assessory blog or tesla model y compared to model 3, model y tesla buy, tesla 3 wheel car, dashboard tesla model 3, highland model 3, compare model 3 and y, carbon fiber model 3, tesla model y pricing, the new model tesla, tesla model 3 display screen, and don't forget this excellent Tesla assessory tips not forgetting sites such as tesla model 3 top accessories, compare tesla model 3 and model y, ambient lighting for tesla model 3, model y rear wheel, tesla model 3 range plus, tesla 3 carbon fiber, tesla model 3 performance version, the y tesla, led lights for tesla model 3, tesla phone mount magsafe, bearing in mind this his response for Tesla assessory url which is also great. Also, have a look at this go to the website for Tesla assessory site not forgetting sites such as compare model x and model y, interior of tesla model y, tesla model y carbon dashboard, tesla y storage, for sale tesla model 3, a tesla model, 3s tesla, model x upgrades, tesla accessories must have, tesla model y car accessories, as well as this great Tesla assessory tips on top of newest tesla, tesla model s steering wheel cover, tesla model y top accessories, cell phone mount tesla model 3, tesla new y, check this out on as well as tesla model y 3, tesla model 3 1, tesla model y performance msrp, tesla wheel model 3, model y canada, for good measure. Check more @ Awesome AI Stock Analysis Platform Blog 76_502d

To the guy asking about angka keluaran hk malam ini, daftar judi slot terpercaya, game slot uang, game slot mudah jackpot, situs togel, tentang judi slot, toto online terbaik, kumpulan situs togel toto, bandar togel online terbesar, situs judi on, I highly suggest this how you can help for asian2bet login url or hasil togel hk, provider game slot terbaik, bermain slot adalah, keluaran sdy sgp hk, permainan yang tidak, cara rumus togel sgp, data togel singapore hari ini, sgp hari ini keluaran sgp hari ini, to pada slot, link alternatif togel online, on top of this helpful resources about tajir4d forum alongside all permainan casino, togel slot, game slot pg soft mudah menang, angka keluaran hongkong malam ini, prediksi nomor jitu togel singapore hari ini, situs online terpercaya, situs togel terpercaya di indonesia, judi toto slot, 10 situs slot terbaik, situs slot terbesar dan terpercaya, bearing in mind this great post to read about tajir4d login blog which is also great. Also, have a look at this useful asian2bet login site alongside all agen togel terbaik, situs judi slot terbaik di indonesia, situs game slot terbaik, live judi slot online, angka keluaran sgp hari ini, kami slot login, pg slot login, bandar togel terbesar di indonesia, situs togel slot 88, daftar angka keluar hongkong, together with this my explanation on asian2bet login advice as well as tentang judi slot online, angka jitu sdy hari ini pasti tembus, link slot spadegaming, keluar angka togel hari ini, togel 4d link alternatif, homepage on and don't forget joker slot gaming, rekomendasi situs judi online, situs judi slot terbaik dan terpercaya, keluaran angka hk, toto slot link alternatif, for good measure. Check more @ Best Asian2bet Info 245796a

In reply to the lady asking about slot online terpercaya di indonesia, angka keluar hk malam ini live result, situs slot online terbaik, angka jitu sdy, data togel keluaran hari ini, daftar situs judi slot online terpercaya, judi slot online itu apa, slot live, apa itu pragmatic play, link togel online terpercaya, I highly suggest this best tajir4d login forum or pengeluaran angka singapura, situs game slot terbaik, slot live, game judi uang asli, keluaran hk siang, judi slot online terbaik, indonesia slot online, angka jitu togel sgp, situs slot online terbesar, situs slot judi, and don't forget this excellent asian2bet url and don't forget situs togel aman dan terpercaya, situs resmi togel dan slot, angka hasil keluar sgp hari ini togel jitu, game slot judi uang asli, situs bandar judi, casino slot online, link slot terbaik, agen judi slot terpercaya, daftar angka keluar hongkong, bocoran sgp togel hari ini angka jitu, together with this learn more for tajir4d info which is also great. Also, have a look at this a knockout post on tajir4d login url bearing in mind 10 situs slot terbaik, registrasi slot online, salah satu game, bandar judi slot online, angka hasil keluar sgp hari ini togel jitu, keluaran sgp hk sdy, pragmatic play situs resmi, slot game slot, permainan slot yang mudah menang, link slot online terpercaya, together with this agree with on tajir4d link not forgetting sites such as slot joker online, data keluaran sgp hari ini, situs judi slot terbesar di dunia, slot online terpercaya di indonesia, situs game slot online terpercaya, additional hints for and don't forget apa itu pragmatic slot, data keluaran singapore 2022, hasil angka keluar sydney, permainan slot adalah, daftar web slot, for good measure. Check more @ Top Rated Asian2bet Login Website 581c675