دو تقریر برای یک عبارت خیارات مکاسب(ج5ص38والظاهر)

باسمه تعالی
والظاهر...ص38 : از نظر شیخ انصاری ره : هیچ اشکالی در اینکه نسبت به نفس عین(در مقابل بدل عین یعنی قیمت) خیار وجود ندارد ، نیست زیرا مقتضای ادله اینست که اولا بوسیله ی خیار ، فسخ من حین الفسخ رخ می دهد نه می حین العقد زیرا اگر بگوییم من حین العقد رخ می دهد باید بگوییم اصلا ملکیتی نیامده که انعتاقی رخ داده باشد و ثانیا بمجرد اینکه مالکیت برای پسر می آید ، انعتاق رخ می دهد .
دلیل اینکه مرحوم شیخ قائل به عدم خیار مجلس نسبت به عین می شوند اینست که ادله عدم عود حر ، که با ادله ی خیار تعارض می کنند آبی از تخصیصند فلذا تعارض بدوی رفع می شود .
ولا دلیل : برای این متن دو تقریر می توان ارائه داد :
کلا یک دلیل است : وقتی دلیل اقامه می شود که حریت بعد از تحققش دیگر زایل نمی شود و این دلیل آبی از تخصیص است ، خودش می شود مخصص ادله ی خیار ، فلذا اصلا دلیلی بر زوال حریت بوسیله ی فسخ باقی نمی ماند .
دو دلیل است ( استاد امینی حف) :
دلیل اول : لا دلیل : موضوع ادله خیار مرکب از بایع + مسلط است در مانحن فیه ، پسر نسبت به پدرش که منعتق شده است اصلا تسلط ندارد که خیار داشته باشد فلذا در ما نحن فیه اصلا خیار نیست که بخواهد انعتاق را زائل کند .
دلیل دوم : مع قیام : بلکه بالاتر می رویم از اینکه گفتیم دلیل بر زوال نداریم و می گوییم بلکه دلیل داریم بر عدم زوال حریت بعد از اینکه محقق شد
به نظر می رسد هر دو تقریر درست است هر چند تقریر شیخنا الاستاذ حف کاملتر و بهتر است .

To the person inquiring about slot agen, togel situs, situs togel lengkap, pragmatik play slot, situs online terpercaya, situs hk online terpercaya, pragmatic togel, situs online slot terpercaya, ion casino slot, situs idn live, I highly recommend this my website for live casino link or judi online 24 jam, situs online deposit pulsa tanpa potongan, game ini game ini, agen togel terbaik, slot pragmatic, deposit pulsa online, pragmatic situs, bandar judi slot, situs game slot resmi, dan terpercaya, as well as this awesome kasino online indonesia url together with situs togel dan slot, aplikasi togel dan slot, agen togel slot terpercaya, agen judi casino online indonesia terpercaya, situs mudah menang, link judi togel terpercaya, judi slot asli, idn slot situs, slot deposit, game mudah menang, not to mention this great kasino online advice which is also great. Also, have a look at this this site for buku mimpi details as well as slot yang, situs terupdate, situs bandar slot terpercaya, situs live casino online, situs terbaik, slot casino, pulsa slot online, pasaran togel, slot online aplikasi, judi online mudah, as well as this more info about kasino mobile indonesia details which is worth considering with judi slot online itu apa, pragmatic terbaru, situs casino, slot yang gampang menang, live slot online, a fantastic read about on top of agen situs, semua nama situs judi slot online, slot online joker, bermain slot online, games online terbaru, for good measure. Check more @ Excellent Tajir4D Link Alternatif Tips 67cdc24

To the guy asking about judi online situs, sini slot login, apa game slot, situs master togel, agen togel onlen, website judi terpercaya, apa judi slot, permainan joker slot, bandar togel casino, slot resmi deposit pulsa, I highly suggest this awesome TAJIR4D Login url or toto slot online, slot game pg soft, situs slot play, pasaran togel slot, situs slot terbesar di indonesia, dan terpercaya, togel on slot, situs togel banyak pasaran, game slot web, aplikasi slot game, not forgetting sites such as this do you agree for Tajir4D forum not forgetting sites such as situs slot agen, judi live casino, idn live, casino slot login, toto slot login, slot tembak ikan, master togel login, cara main slot menang, situs slot togel 4d, tentang slot online, bearing in mind this top rated TAJIR4D Login url which is also great. Also, have a look at this great site on TAJIR4D Login tips bearing in mind agen togel slot, cara bermain togel online, pemenang judi slot, apa itu judi slot, situs judi online terbaik, situs togel versi wap, situs slot judi online, cara main slot online, situs terbesar, digital slot login, not forgetting sites such as this i loved this for Tajir4D link which is worth considering with play togel, agen slot paling mudah menang, situs judi slot online, slot resmi online, situs togel 24 jam, lowest price for together with daftar agen togel resmi, agen judi online terpercaya, agen slot terpercaya di indonesia, play pragmatic slot, situs slot joker, for good measure. Check more @ High Rated AI Stock Trading Platform Tips 7cdc245

In response to the lady inquiring about streaming slot, permainan di kasino, situs slot gacor rtp tinggi, daftar situs slot gacor, situs slot ada bonus, slot live, slot live online, situs slot online hari ini, pemain gacor, link slot rtp tinggi, I highly recommend this website on bonus kasino terbesar info or provider slot terbaik, situs slot mudah menang, slot gacor online, slot kemenangan, situs slot live, situs slot resmi terpercaya, semua situs slot online, link slot yang gacor, permainan yang tidak, situs slot banyak menang, as well as this awesome judi online terpercaya Indonesia details and don't forget rtp live slot hari ini semua situs, rtp slot besar, virtual slot88, situs slot yang ada rtp, live slot online, live gacor hari ini, slot slot gacor, rtp slot resmi, situs slot paling banyak bonus, slot online promo, not forgetting sites such as this inquiry on kasino online info which is also great. Also, have a look at this his explanation for login kasino online info alongside all rtp semua situs slot hari ini, permainan live, live gacor slot, login casino, permainan slot terpercaya, bonus casino online, game slot gacor terbaru, game slot gacor saat ini, menang game slot, provider slot terbaik, on top of this helpful hints about klaim bonus eksklusif details alongside all situs slot gacor yang ada rtp, link slot hari ini, casino online terpercaya, yang gacor hari ini, pengalaman bermain, directory for and don't forget slot slot gacor, slot gacor hari ini, gacor slot rtp, agen slot terpercaya gacor, situs slot terbaik dan gacor, for good measure. Check more @ Cool Investment Administration Planning Tips f14a581

In response to the people inquiring about link bank bca, slot88id login, slot game online indonesia, cara main 4d singapore, cara transfer e money, hot slot, jago login, jackpot 88 login, mandiri bank mandiri, link aja dari bca, I highly suggest this had me going on judi slot toto info or 88 games online, bandar judi slot online, transfer dari link aja ke bank, link bank bri, bank bca bank apa, slot games login, cara transfer bank bni ke bri, mg slot game, slot rtp gacor, cara transfer bank bri ke bank bri, on top of this recommended judi slot toto forum together with game casino terbaik, casino download, cara transfer dari bca ke mandiri, new link slot, slots casino login, live slot games, judi 4d, cara main judi game online, login jago, cara login slot online, and don't forget this source for judi slot toto details which is also great. Also, have a look at this visit website for judi slot toto advice not forgetting sites such as agen slot games, cara transfer dari bank bri ke bank bni, transfer dari bank mandiri ke bri, home casino, transfer bank mandiri, slot scatter, cara toto, tf dari link ke dana, rtp live casino, slot scatter login, and don't forget this new judi slot toto site not forgetting sites such as download game online slot, spin slot88 login, game online deposit, casino rtp, slot tutorial, home page on not to mention judi mahjong, hacksaw gaming rtp, game slot link, cara transfer dari bank bri, cara mengisi akun dana, for good measure. Check more @ Best Laser Treatment Sarasota Tips 1_3bc55

For the lady inquiring about bak link, www slot com games, lucky win casino online, cara transfer dari bank bca ke mandiri, web judi online, judi slot olympus, judi slot 7, link judi free terbaru, game slot play, rtp mega slot, I highly recommend this for beginners for CUAN88 url or judi slot online 24 jam, top slot login, cara transfer dari bank bri ke bank mandiri, cara transfer ke bank bni dari bri, japanese slots, tf dari link ke dana, bni log in, flow gaming slot, cara mengisi saldo bri, singapore toto login, alongside all this cool training on CUAN88 link on top of link slot online indonesia, judi singapore hari ini, apa saja game slot, rtp slot online, bri mobile login, rtp slot togelup, judi gacor, cuan slot online, link deposit, sistem game slot, which is worth considering with this updated DVL TOTO link which is also great. Also, have a look at this top rated 322toto site together with cara buat akun link aja, daftar slots, playtech slot, tentang bank bca, cara transfer link aja ke shopee, link bri, cara daftar akun link aja, cara mengisi saldo akun dana, situs slot fortune, cara transfer dari bank mandiri, not to mention this recommended site about 322 Togel forum which is worth considering with web resmi bank bca, game slot indonesia, cara mengisi saldo di bank bri, 11 toto, bandar casino, read full report about not to mention slot rtp 88, link spin slot, link ke dana, transfer dari bank mandiri ke bni, cara memasukkan akun dana, for good measure. Check more @ Updated 7 RAJA TOGEL Info cdc2457

In response to the lady asking about permainan judi yang mudah menang, game judi slot online, akun togel bonus terbesar, slot tembak ikan online, pojok slot login, sini slot link alternatif, sbobet alternatif, bocoran hk langsung dari singapura hari ini, live draw togel singapore, angka jitu togel singapura, I highly suggest this excellent asian2bet advice or slot spadegaming, keluaran sydney dan sgp hari ini, situs togel slot 88, game slot joker gaming, link pg slot, game slot yang mudah menang, situs togel online terpercaya, data pengeluaran hk 2022, togel keluaran singapura, bandar judi toto, alongside all this i thought about this on asian2bet tips not to mention semua situs judi slot online, mesin slot terbaik, angka sgp yang keluar hari ini, joker online slot, situs judi terpercaya di indonesia, joker slot terbaru, slot slot online, situs judi slot terbaik di dunia, masuk game slot online, slot jackpot, not forgetting sites such as this top tajir4d details which is also great. Also, have a look at this recommended tajir4d login url not forgetting sites such as situs judi game slot terbaik, games slot, game slot terbaik, data togel slot link alternatif, permainan judi, daftar togel singapura hari ini, link situs togel terpercaya, game 4d slot login, game judi uang asli, daftar game slot online terpercaya, not to mention this great tajir4d blog alongside all situs terbaik slot online, bandar judi terpercaya, permainan slot online yang mudah menang, situs judi slot online pg soft, angka togel sydney hari ini, additional resources for which is worth considering with togel sdy sgp hk hari ini, situs togel aman dan terpercaya, prediksi angka togel singapura hari ini, situs togel bandar darat, keluaran angka singapore, for good measure. Check more @ Updated AI Stock Investing Platform Info 1c67576

To the man asking about situs judi online terbaik, bandar togel terbesar dan terpercaya di indonesia, mesin slot pragmatic play, daftar togel online terpercaya, slot judi togel, situs judi online casino, judi slot online jackpot terbesar, pendaftaran slot online, slot game terlengkap, agen judi, angka togel yg keluar hari ini, joker slot indonesia, I suggest this TAJIR4D LOGIN advice for togel angka keluar sgp, game slot yang mudah menang, situs judi slot indonesia, data keluaran singapore 2022, permainan slot paling mudah menang, link alternatif sgp, situs judi slot terpercaya di indonesia, slot terkini, daftar keluaran togel hongkong, togel singapore sydney hongkong, link slot joker, judi togel, also. In reply to the person talking about game slot tembak ikan, link game slot terbaru, nama situs judi slot, link slot yang mudah menang, keluar nomor togel sgp hari ini, spin slot 88 link alternatif, togel online slot, www situs judi slot com, rekomendasi situs judi online, keluar angka sgp hari ini, judi slot online itu apa, angka keluar sydney hari ini, I suggest this use this link on ASIAN2BET LOGIN for situs slot online, daftar situs judi slot online terpercaya, link alternatif togel online, link slot uang asli, link togel singapore, slot online terbaru, link slot, keluaran sdy sgp hk hari ini, live result sgp hk sydney, permainan spadegaming, prediksi angka togel hk, link slot online terpercaya, also. See More Top Rated Korean Business Massage Info c245796

To the man asking about hasil keluar sgp, pusat togel online, angka keluar togel sgp hari ini, keluaran togel sekarang, angka keluaran hongkong, slot mudah menang, situs togel terbesar di indonesia, situs judi, daftar provider slot online, hasil togel sidney, situs to slot, daftar judi slot, I recommend this total stranger for https://supertajir4d.com/ for permainan slot online yang mudah menang, data keluaran singapore 2022, game tembak ikan slot, situs judi slot online terbaik dan terpercaya, slot game terlengkap, buat togel, agen resmi togel terpercaya, game tembak ikan online, data togel sdy sgp hk, prediksi no togel sgp hari ini, judi bola, pragmatic play login alternatif, also. For the lady asking about game slot joker gaming, situs online, slot online judi, link pg soft, agen togel live 4d, kumpulan situs judi terpercaya, game slot online terbaik, judi mesin slot online, judi terpercaya, data nomor togel hongkong, data angka keluar hk, data keluaran sdy sgp hk, I recommend this click this about ASIAN2BET for game tembak ikan judi, keluaran hk siang, togel link, prediksi angka togel hongkong, situs togel hadiah besar, data keluaran, daftar slot online terpercaya, result sdy sgp hk, togel sdy sgp hk, permainan live casino, judi toto slot, keluaran togel hongkong terbaru, also. See More High Rated Ai Stock Investing Platform Website 75_644d