تقریر درس خارج اصول استاد قائنی 20 اسفند؛ بیان کلام شهید صدر در قاعده الجمع مهما أمکن

[حائری علی اصغر]

بسم الله الرّحمن الرّحیم
مرحوم آقای صدر فرموده می¬توان قاعده «الجمع مهما أمکن» را وفق قاعده جمع عرفی تبیین نمود و نتیجه این می شود که در غالب موارد تعارض ، تعارض مستقرّ نخواهد بود.
برای تطبیق این بیان ، دو مثال بیان می کنیم :
مثال اول که در آن جمع موضوعی می کنیم :
در تعارض بین «لا بأس ببیع العذرة» و «ثمن العذرة سحت» هر کدام از این دو جمله ، دو دلالت دارد که یکی بالنصوصیّة است و دیگری بالظهور است و بواسطه نصّ هرکدام در ظهور دیگری تصرّف می کنیم. توضیح ذلک :
اسم جنس وضع شده برای طبیعت مهمله فلذا هرگاه استعمال شود ، آن جمله نصّ در ثبوت حکم برای طبیعت بنحو قضیه مهمله است. مقدمات حکمت هم منشأ برای ظهور کلام در طبیعت مطلقه می شود و هرگاه در کلامی تمام باشند ، منشأ برای ظهور ثبوت حکم برای طبیعت بنحو اطلاق است.
هر کدام از این دو جمله ، این دو دلالت را دارند و تعارض کنونی بین حکم مهمل در هرجمله با حکم مطلق در جمله دیگر است ؛ واضح است که در این موارد بواسطه نصّ یک کلام از ظهور کلام معارضش رفع ید می کنیم.
پس هر جمله قدر متیقنی دارد که بالنصوصیة دالّ بر آن است و در موارد تعارض بواسطه همین قدر متیقن در دلیل معارض تصرف می کنیم و از ظهورش رفع ید می کنیم.

مثال دوم که در آن جمع حکمی می کنیم :
اگر یک دلیل از عملی نهی کرد و دلیل دیگر تصریح به اباحه داشت (بنحوی که متباینین بودند) ، در اینگونه موارد بین دلیلین جمع حکمی می کنیم : دلیلی که تصریح به اباحه داشت ، نصّ در جواز ارتکاب و ظاهر در اباحه بالمعنی الأخصّ است. دلیلی هم که ناهی بود ، نصّ در مبغوضیّت و ظاهر در حرمت و عدم جواز ارتکاب است. نتیجه اخذ به نصّ هر دو دلیل اینست که بگوئیم آن دلیل مبغوض ولی جایز است یعنی مکروه است ؛ بواسطه دو نصّ ، از دو ظاهر رفع ید کردیم.

نتیجه : قاعده الجمع مهما أمکن ، وفق جمع عرفی است.
سپس مرحوم شهید صدر به این بیان ، اشکال می کنند :
مفاد جمع مهما أمکن ، این نیست که موارد جمع عرفی را هم شامل شود زیرا در جمع عرفی ، مفاد دلیل ظهور در معنای محقِّق جمع دارد ولی در قاعده جمع مهما أمکن اینگونه نیست که دلیل معارض، بالخصوص متعرض آن معنای محقِّق جمع باشد بلکه بالإطلاق دال بر معنایی است و آن معنی عقلا مستلزم معنای محقِّق جمع است. در مثال اول هم گفته شد که «لا بأس ببیع العذرة» نصّ در «نفی بأس فی الجملة» است نه اینکه بالخصوص نفی بأس فی الجملة کرده باشد.
پس اگر دلالت قضیه بالخصوص و بالظهور نباشد و از باب قدر متیقن باشد ، جمع عرفی محسوب نمی شود ؛ قدر متیقن ، ظهور نمی سازد.

تحقیق الکلام : تعارض سه قسم است :
1. یک دلیل ، معنایی دارد و دلیل معارضش بالظهور الخاص دلالت بر نقطه جمع دارد ؛ جمع عرفی است.
2. دلالت دلیل بر نقطه جمع و معنای محقِّق جمع ، بالخصوص نیست بلکه استلزام عقلی است. قدر متیقنی است که لازمه ثبوت حکم است (مثلا اگر حکم ممنوعیت بر عذرة باشد ، قطعا بر عذرة نجس هست و اینکه فقط برای عذرة غیر نجس باشد قبیح است. یا اینکه اگر جواز بیع عذره باشد قطعا برای عذره غیر نجس هست و اگر فقط برای خصوص عذره نجس باشد قبیح است.) ؛ همین موارد قاعده الجمع مهما أمکن است که جمع عرفی در آن وجود ندارد.
3. گاهی دلالت دو کلام اجمال دارد ولی اگر قرار باشد هر دو درست باشد ، باید هرکدام را حمل بر معنایی کرد. در این موارد جمع عرفی نیست ولی نتیجه جمع عرفی هست. مثال فقهی : تحدید کرّ در روایت ابن ابی عمیر «1200 رطل» و در روایت محمد بن مسلم «600 رطل» وارد شده و نمی دانیم که رطل عراقی مراد است یا رطل مکی ولی این را می دانیم که رطل مکی دو برابر رطل عراقی است. دلیل حجیّت گفته که هر دو خبر ثقه هستند پس هر دو را تصدیق کن ؛ عقلاً اگر بخواهیم هر دو را تصدیق کنیم ناچاریم از اینکه اولی را حمل کنیم بر رطل عراقی و دومی را حمل کنیم بر رطل مکی. حکم «تعبد به صدور» حکم «علم به صدور» است ؛ اگر علم به صدور این دو داشتیم ، علم میداشتیم که هر دو صادق بوده و همین محمل را دارند ؛ اکنون نیز که متعبد به صدور شده ایم ، هینگونه حمل می کنیم.

[FrankJScott]

To the man asking about share analysis software, share trading software, using ai to invest, invest in ai companies, open ai on the stock market, best stock prediction app, ai gpt stock, about stock trading, learn how to analyze stocks, ai stock program, I highly recommend this listen to this podcast about AI stock predictions analysis advice (https://healthshopmall.com/20-good-suggestions-for-choosing-ai-stock-picker-platform-websites/) or study stocks, ai stocks to buy now, ai and stock trading, ai companies nasdaq, data analysis in stock market, stock trend analysis, stock market advice, stocks and investing, best sites for stock research, artificial technology stocks, on top of this click here about AI stock picker analysis url (https://behkarnama.online/2025/05/15/20-recommended-reasons-on-choosing-ai-stock-investing-analysis-websites/) on top of stock market ai, ai for trading stocks, ai startup stocks to buy, best ai stock to buy, ai and the stock market, stock chart predictor, best stock market tools, stock buying software, stock market and how to invest, ai to buy and sell stocks, together with this useful AI stock picker analysis tips (https://hefeituangou.com/20-handy-info-for-deciding-on-ai-stock-picker-platform-websites-2/) which is also great. Also, have a look at this a fantastic read on AI stock picker analysis info (https://ahrsy.com/20-pro-suggestions-for-selecting-ai-stock-investing-platform-websites/) and don't forget ai stock analysis software, best stock pick, ai companies on nasdaq, trading and stock market, ai chat stock, stock trading prediction software, ai nasdaq stocks, predict stock price, ai trading apps, best investment analysis websites, which is worth considering with this useful AI stock predictions analysis forum (https://antiguamecomefrom.com/20-pro-info-for-choosing-ai-stock-predictions-analysis-sites/) which is worth considering with stock software, stock prediction app, best artificial intelligence stocks, ai stocks to buy, the best stock analysis websites, that guy on (https://spencerslam03703.shivawiki.com) as well as stock gpt, bot stock trading, artificial investment, website for stock analysis, best free stock analysis app, for good measure. Check more @ Best Tajir4D Link Alternatif Website (https://forum.zanjantkr.ir/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=17035&p=18208#p18208) 4a581c6

[FrankJScott]

In response to the lady asking about best stock investment tools, best sites to analyse stocks, stock picking sites, best investment analysis websites, stocks in trading, top stock analysis apps, stock ai companies, best stock valuation website, investment ai software, stock chat gpt, I highly recommend this more info about AI stock trading analysis forum (https://casinoeasy.site/20-best-suggestions-for-deciding-on-ai-stock-picker-platform-websites/) or shares in artificial intelligence, best sites for stock research, using ai to invest, best stock research app, best free stock analysis app, ai based stocks, stock trading ai bot, ai revolution stocks, cheap ai stocks, best free stock analysis tools, not to mention this learn more for AI stock investing platform site (https://wa-ttth.com/20-excellent-ideas-for-deciding-on-ai-stock-picker-platform-sites/) and don't forget artificial intelligence stock trading software, buy open ai stock, best app for stock selection, best ai stock picker, stock trading advice, ai stock app, best artificial intelligence stocks to buy now, ai stock portfolio, stock market tools for analysis, best stock market analysis tools, not forgetting sites such as this great AI stock investing analysis advice (https://bin-7799.com/20-top-reasons-on-choosing-ai-stock-investing-analysis-websites/) which is also great. Also, have a look at this agree with about AI stock investing platform link (https://lwgzurn.com/20-recommended-tips-to-picking-ai-stock-picker-platform-sites/) together with best ai technology stocks, ai trading tools, ai software for stock market, ai stocks nasdaq, stocks to invest in ai, stock picker app, best stock analyzer, chat gpt for investing, machine learning stocks, best ai investments, not forgetting sites such as this this hyperlink for AI stock picker analysis forum (https://mitaocun.com/2025/05/15/20-handy-suggestions-to-picking-ai-stock-picker-platform-sites/) bearing in mind best stock analysis software, best site for stock, top artificial intelligence stocks, website for stock analysis, best platform for stock analysis, learn more for (https://arthurqhmn09012.activablog.com) alongside all website stock market, best ai stock trading bot, ai investment bot, gpt ai stock, stock analysis tools free, for good measure. Check more @ Recommended TAJIR4D Tips (https://forum.toyotaklub.org.pl/index.php?topic=1401.new#new) 796a07c

[FrankJScott]

To the lady asking about 4 d slot, menang togel online, joker slot online, slot resmi singapore, link togel slot online, main judi slot online, situs agen, game online slot terpercaya, bandar togel terbesar dan terpercaya di indonesia, situs slot game online, I highly suggest this useful Tajir4D tips (https://travisabvs77777.bloggactif.com/36602009/30-excellent-info-to-deciding-on-tajir4d-login-websites) or slot situs terpercaya, web slot resmi, slot yang bisa deposit pulsa, sini slot login, cara main slot online, situs slot yang resmi, aplikasi game slot online, slot games slot, online situs, bandar togel online terbesar, which is worth considering with this homepage about Tajir4D forum (https://travisabvs77777.bloggactif.com/36602008/30-top-info-on-choosing-tajir4d-login-websites) which is worth considering with permainan game slot online, judi online terbaik, situs slot live, situs togel terbaik, slot games slot, agen judi casino online indonesia terpercaya, situs game pragmatic, judi online terbesar, cara main casino online, judi slot online itu apa, and don't forget this top TAJIR4D Login blog (https://emilianowlym42086.kylieblog.com/35829001/30-top-facts-to-picking-tajir4d-sites) which is also great. Also, have a look at this recommended you read for Tajir4D forum (https://johnnykolg04948.wikiworldstock.com/1509425/30_free_reasons_for_selecting_tajir4d_login_websit es) which is worth considering with bermain slot, agen situs slot online terpercaya, daftar situs judi slot online resmi, slot casino indonesia, bandar judi slot, bandar togel casino, judi togel slot, situs slot terpercaya di indonesia, togel terbesar di indonesia, situs slot yang terpercaya, as well as this updated blog post on TAJIR4D Login site (https://fernandosjwc79247.ivasdesign.com/56624039/30-new-reasons-for-selecting-tajir4d-login-websites) as well as joker slot deposit pulsa, game slot live, situs togel slot, situs togel yang aman dan terpercaya, di togel slot, do you agree for (https://fernandoyfgg28407.total-blog.com) not to mention game slot online adalah, situs online terpercaya, rekomendasi situs judi slot online, bermain togel, slot joker gaming, for good measure. Check more @ Best Pyeongtaek Business Massage Site (https://play.thronesofdestiny.com/showthread.php?tid=5483&pid=23956#pid23956) 7cf14a5

[FrankJScott]

To the man talking about cara ke bank, cara transfer di bank bni, hot slots online, cara main judi slot, bgaming slot, rtp slot online, link aja indonesia, jackpot game online, web resmi bank bri, aplikasi bank mandiri, I highly suggest this breaking news on judi slot toto link (https://beauoqok66666.bligblogging.com/36237189/30-great-tips-for-choosing-cuan88-websites) or slot online nexus, games casino, game casino terbaik, hades slot, cara transfer, online slot app, link judi ewallet, apa itu bank bri, e money bisa digunakan untuk, cara mengisi dana slot, on top of this extra resources on judi slot toto forum (https://gunnerkudm30852.blogdeazar.com/35763820/30-pro-pieces-of-advice-for-deciding-on-dvltoto-sites) bearing in mind informasi bank, transfer bank bri ke bank mandiri, bca perbankan, jenius dana, link ke dana, nama nama bandar togel, slot casino online indonesia, agen bni login, cara transfer, link aplikasi, which is worth considering with this what do you think about judi slot toto url (https://damienqdmw64186.mpeblog.com/62484669/30-best-ways-for-deciding-on-7-raja-togel-sites) which is also great. Also, have a look at this these details about judi slot toto url (https://zaneelmi88901.wiki-promo.com/668562/30_excellent_suggestions_for_picking_cuan88_websit es) not forgetting sites such as e money untuk, cara mengisi data bank bri, judi slot hari ini, play lucky slots, cuan88 slot online, slots indonesia, tiger fortune slot, bandar judi terbaik, link aja indonesia, live judi slot, bearing in mind this the full details for judi slot toto site (https://gregoryocpa97531.goabroadblog.com/34609912/30-recommended-suggestions-for-choosing-7-raja-togel-websites) bearing in mind tiger slots, games jackpot, link ke bca, bca link aja, 4d judi, funny post on (https://augustqpkd22100.slypage.com) and don't forget slot game link, judi slot game, cara transfer dari bank mandiri, akun link aja, english slots, for good measure. Check more @ Awesome Tajir4D Website (https://www.dorminantus.de/thread-375833-post-1369167.html#pid1369167) f71_194

[FrankJScott]

For the person talking about toto judi slot, slot online slot, cara transfer dari bank bri, judi online 24 jam, tentang bank bca, link slot promo, bg slot online, slot japanese, cara dana transfer ke bank bri, informasi bank, I highly suggest this this post about 322toto tips (https://directory-nation.com/listings13524615/slot-game-dan-link-slot-online) or cara mengisi saldo game online, rp casino, slot arcade, download slot games, slot android, main toto, bank bca mandiri, main slot 88 login, slot88 casino online, rtp slot, which is worth considering with this top rated DVL TOTO link (https://easton1j74jlj2.wikitidings.com/user) and don't forget sini slot online, panda spin 88 login, bantuan dari bank, toto judi, lucky 88 slots, game slot 88 online, bandar judi terbaik, pp games slot, bandar casino, joker slot game login, on top of this resources about DVLTOTO link (https://nathaniel0x98zcd1.wikibestproducts.com/user) which is also great. Also, have a look at this these details about DVLTOTO advice (https://landon4d88frz1.dekaronwiki.com/user) and don't forget fortune game slot, ovo dana, bgaming slot, cara mengisi saldo di aplikasi dana, joker casino online, game slot online deposit dana, cara tf dari bank mandiri ke bca, panda cuan slot, web judi gacor, evolution slot, and don't forget this excellent 322 Togel tips (https://daniel5o63lhc8.wikigdia.com/user) on top of jackpot judi slot online, game slot mobile, sport toto singapore 4d, cara memasukan saldo dana, pay telkomsel, enquiry about (https://troyzsiu37147.losblogos.com) on top of cara mengisi dana bca, kode rtp slot, rtp in slot, cara transfer rekening mandiri ke dana, aplikasi yang bisa untuk, for good measure. Check more @ Recommended Cross Body Phone Case Website (https://www.flcolle.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=4859&pid=8868&page=1&extra=#pid8868) 67cdc24

[FrankJScott]

In reply to the man asking about situs judi online casino, angka togel hk, link slot pg soft, situs judi slot online 4d, game slot online terbaru, slot ug gaming, keluaran togel sidney hari ini, slot online, game mudah menang, 5 bandar togel terpercaya, I highly recommend this awesome tajir4d advice (https://spencervitc07520.blog-ezine.com/36108787/20-good-tips-for-deciding-on-tajir4d-sites) or daftar keluaran togel hongkong, game slot spadegaming yang mudah menang, situs bandar terpercaya, cara menghitung angka keluaran hongkong, angka togel sydney hari ini, data lengkap hari ini, situs slot uang asli, judi toto, data lengkap keluaran sgp, link situs slot online, and don't forget this this post on tajir4d login site (https://judahobuy85284.wikipowell.com/6347622/20_excellent_tips_for_deciding_on_tajir4d_websites ) not forgetting sites such as link togel dan slot, website judi slot terpercaya, bandar togel online terpercaya, situs slot terbesar indonesia, joker123 gaming online, link alternatif, data togel singapore hari ini, situs judi online casino, link daftar togel, angka angka togel, alongside all this recommended tajir4d url (https://garrettfbtj32109.blogtov.com/16440126/20-new-ideas-for-choosing-tajir4d-websites) which is also great. Also, have a look at this find out more about tajir4d login info (https://collinobmw86318.blogkoo.com/20-great-facts-for-deciding-on-tajir4d-websites-55270982) and don't forget bandar judi slot online, situs judi indonesia, permainan judi online, permainan slot judi, game slot login, link to slot, online terpercaya, angka togel jitu, permainan spadegaming, slot situs terbaik, not to mention this high rated tajir4d login advice (https://jeffreywjsw24680.like-blogs.com/35681723/20-free-pieces-of-advice-for-deciding-on-tajir4d-websites) and don't forget situs online slot terbaik, angka jitu sdy hari ini pasti tembus, di slot, situs judi slot online indonesia, game slot yang gampang menang, link for (https://andrefqwz34679.diowebhost.com) which is worth considering with agen judi slot, nama situs judi slot, bocoran togel sdy, agen online terpercaya, judi slot game, for good measure. Check more @ Cool Business Trust Planning Website (https://www.passived.de/forum/showthread.php?tid=4657&pid=200956#pid200956) 757664f

[FrankJScott]

For the man asking about link judi togel terpercaya, link judi slot, tentang judi slot online, togel 4d slot, kumpulan situs slot terbaik, togel online slot, main slot login, keluaran togel hongkong, bermain judi slot, togel online daftar, I highly suggest this additional reading for asian2bet blog (https://getsocialselling.com/story5258364/withdraw-slot-dan-situs-baru) or situs judi on, mesin slot link, situs togel online indonesia, link slot joker, masuk game slot, agen togel dan slot, link togel terbaik, mesin slot judi, pengeluaran togel hk, situs togel terbesar, not forgetting sites such as this the advantage about asian2bet advice (https://bookmarkerz.com/story19708268/judi-slot-online-dan-situs-online) bearing in mind to pada slot, situs judi slot mudah menang, bandar judi togel online, nama situs judi slot online, link judi togel terbaik, pusat judi online, keluar angka sgp, sgp hari ini keluaran sgp hari ini, slot login, angka togel singapore, which is worth considering with this great tajir4d login site (https://opensocialfactory.com/story21607197/slot-pragmatik-play-dan-login-slot) which is also great. Also, have a look at this experienced about tajir4d login tips (https://jonathan9a69jud5.weblogco.com/profile) not forgetting sites such as judi togel, angka keluaran togel hari ini, link game slot terbaru, slot tembak ikan, keluaran sdy sgp hk, keuntungan bermain slot online, hasil pengeluaran hk, slot game online terpercaya, judi slot pg, keluaran togel sydney hari ini, and don't forget this click this for asian2bet login tips (https://2020-directory.com/listings13243900/judi-bola-terpercaya-dan-online-situs) which is worth considering with prediksi angka sgp, daftar judi, bocoran togel sgp hari ini, data keluar singapura hari ini, situs judi online terbaik, my latest blog post for (https://rafaelkmco75309.therainblog.com) alongside all link slot terpercaya di indonesia, slot spadegaming mudah menang, link situs judi slot online terbaik, link game slot terpercaya, link slot online terbaru, for good measure. Check more @ High Rated Tesla Accessories Info (https://odessamama.net/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=265669&pid=477018&page=1&extra=#pid477018) 14a581c

[FrankJScott]

To the person talking about group cyber, it and security solutions, future of information security, cyber security schedule, the information security, ot threats, cyber cluster, best courses cyber security, cyber security qualifications for beginners, about computer security, I highly suggest this how you can help on Dubai cyber security service advice (https://cristianipgi17307.wikirecognition.com/1604941/30_recommended_ideas_for_choosing_a_cybersecurity_ company_in_dubai) or cyber industry, pos cyber, security technology management, cyber security groups, security and forensics, overview of internet security, information security banking, best website to learn cyber security, cyber solutions, internet security websites, alongside all this recommended you read about UAE cyber security service details (https://dallaspmhz10098.dreamyblogs.com/36390137/30-new-ways-for-deciding-on-a-cybersecurity-company-in-dubai) not forgetting sites such as cybersecurity reading, secure it security company, future cyber threats, cybersecurity performance, features of data security, it cyber security solutions, intelligent cybersecurity, saudi cyber, cybersecurity ksa, best courses in cyber security, as well as this helpful site about cybersecurity company in UAE link (https://hectorigas87654.laowaiblog.com/34917544/30-good-tips-for-choosing-a-uae-cyber-security-service) which is also great. Also, have a look at this best cybersecurity company in Dubai info (https://knoxkjcs38260.thenerdsblog.com/41870614/30-handy-suggestions-for-picking-a-uae-cyber-security-service) and don't forget challenges faced by cyber security, security of a company, models for network security, infra security, cyber principles, network security it, cyber and information security technology, areas cyber security, cyber threats to businesses, information and cyber security, alongside all this new cybersecurity company in Dubai blog (https://trentonmbnz97530.wikiap.com/1608233/30_free_ways_for_deciding_on_a_cybersecurity_compa ny_in_uae) alongside all cyber defense tools, management of cyber security, cyber security in cloud, strengthening cyber security, cyber challenges, updated blog post about (https://johnathangrke73661.blogs-service.com) bearing in mind learn about cyber security free, ai cyber defense, cyber security transformation, solutions for cyber security threats, information security can be implemented by, for good measure. Check more @ Top Trust Administration Palm Beach Fl Info (https://grimmoonrp.com/showthread.php?tid=57230&pid=610248#pid610248) 67cdc24