اصول 25 دی

[سید محسن منافی]

اشکالات مرحوم صدر به مرحوم خوئی وارد نمی باشد؛ زیرا همان طور که دلیل بر چیزی، کاشف از ملزوم عقلی است (فلذا گفته می شود که لوازم امارت حجت است.)، کاشف از لوازم شرعی هم هست و فرقی بین مدلول التزامی تکوینی و اثر شرعی نمی باشد. و اشکال مرحوم خوئی به مرحوم نائینی همین است که شما در ملازمات عقلی قائل به کاشفیت هستید، پس باید در ملازمات شرعی هم همین را قائل باشید.
اشکال حلی مرحوم آقای خویی این بود که اخبار از ملاقات لباس با خون، ملازم با مطلق نجاست لباس نیست بلکه ملازم با حصه خاصی از نجاست است که در اثر ملاقات لباس با آن خون خاص حاصل می‌شود، پس وقتی مدلول مطابقی حجت نبود اصلا مدلول التزامی شکل نمی‌گیرد. و در نفی ثالث هم همین طور است یعنی هر دلیل چون مدلول مطابقی خودش را اثبات می‌کند غیر آن را نفی می‌کند و اگر مدلول مطابقی‌اش حجت نباشد، بر نفی غیر آن هم دلالت نمی‌کند.
اشکال مرحوم صدر به جوابِ حلی مرحوم خوئی:
این کلام در لوازم شرعی درست است اما در لوازم عقلی درست نیست. یعنی اخبار از ملاقات لباس با خون، ملازم با مطلق نجاست نیست بلکه ملازم با حصه خاصی از نجاست است و این چون نجاست حصص مختلفی دارد که فقط یک حصه آن با ملاقات با این خون خاص ملازم است اما لوازم عقلی این طور نیستند. لازمه خبر دال بر وجوب نماز جمعه، عدم اباحه آن است نه اینکه لازم آن حصه خاصی از عدم اباحه باشد که مقارن با وجوب آن است. عدم اباحه به طور مطلق از لوازم وجوب شیء‌ است نه اینکه وجوب مستلزم عدم اباحه خاصی است (یعنی مستلزم عدم اباحه مقارن با وجوب نیست) چون این مقارنت با وجوب در حیث استلزام و تاثیر ملزوم در لازم، تاثیری ندارد. درست است که مورد تاثیر وجوب در عدم اباحه مقارن با وجوب است اما این مقارنت در آن تاثیر و استلزام نقشی ندارد و این طور نیست که وجوب فقط مقتضی عدم اباحه مقارن با وجوب باشد بلکه مقتضی مطلق عدم اباحه است هر چند لامحاله در اینجا در عدم اباحه مقارن با وجوب تاثیر کرده است.

[FrankJScott]

In reply to the person asking about best microneedling treatment, aesthetics and laser, skin care peels, laser spas, the best non surgical face treatments, the perfect derma, face rejuvenation, fat lip fillers, non surgical laser face lift, treatment laser, I highly suggest this made my day for laser treatment spots face Sarasota advice (https://24by7directory.com/listings13177916/aesthetics-medical-spa-and-best-treatment-cellulite) or lip filler what is it, dermal lifting, best facial rejuvenation, pdo threads for face, we do aesthetics, male rejuvenation, as skin care, dermal injections, rejuvenation beauty, best non surgical treatment for skin tightening, which is worth considering with this more bonuses on laser treatment Sarasota advice (https://thetopsdirectory.com/listings13166555/vampire-breast-lift-and-spa-sarasota-fl) together with vampire facial peeling, skin tightening non invasive, skin rejuvenation treatment laser, rf microneedling body, cool peel facial, best skin chemical peel, face lifting skin care, vampire face lift near me, renuva fat, medical spa aesthetics, and don't forget this best melasma treatment Sarasota tips (https://austin9u87etf1.blogtov.com/profile) which is also great. Also, have a look at this great pigmentation treatment Sarasota link (https://getmedirectory.com/listings13187808/skin-rejuvenation-treatments-and-plump-lip-injections) not to mention dermal fillers on face, lip injections florida, body and face contouring, faces skin, facial and chemical peel, best non surgical treatment for skin tightening, cool peel, facial laser skin resurfacing, non surgical face lift treatments, shot for cellulite, bearing in mind this awesome laser facial skin treatment advice (https://juan1g94ctl0.corpfinwiki.com/user) together with red light therapy sarasota fl, red light therapy skin products, pdo threads for breast lift, plasma rich injections for hair loss, dermal filler lip injections, link for (https://israeligas10987.acidblog.net) which is worth considering with skin care and laser, aesthetics skin care, red light therapy sarasota, lip augmentation with fat, spa sarasota fl, for good measure. Check more @ Awesome Tajir4D Link Alternatif Guide (https://xinbiao-aicl.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=12883&pid=55018&page=1&extra=page%3D1#pid55018) 664f72_

[FrankJScott]

In response to the people inquiring about ai stock rating, top ai company stocks, stock market tools software, buy ai stock, best website for us stock analysis, best stock trading ai, best artificial intelligence trading software, ai stock portfolio, stock market analysis platform, companies investing in ai, I highly suggest this link for AI stock picker analysis forum (https://jtwmt.com/2025/05/13/20-new-tips-to-picking-ai-stock-picker-platform-sites/) or best stock review sites, ai and the stock market, ai best stocks, ai companies listed on stock market, artificial intelligence stock market prediction software, stock trading tools, stocks to buy now app, advice on stocks, best stock market software, ai related stocks, not to mention this my sources on AI stock trading analysis blog (https://jxstcm.online/2025/05/15/20-great-tips-for-picking-ai-stock-investing-analysis-sites/) on top of best free stock research websites, chat gpt investment, ai technical analysis, top ten ai stocks, stock market for free, ai companies stock, open ai shares, best ai trading system, best ai technology stocks, ai companies on the stock market, which is worth considering with this cool AI stock picker analysis blog (https://finally-europe.com/2025/05/13/20-top-news-on-deciding-on-ai-stock-picker-platform-sites/) which is also great. Also, have a look at this best AI stock investing platform site (https://charuaypontorranin.com/20-excellent-info-for-deciding-on-ai-stock-picker-analysis-websites/) alongside all leading ai stocks, open ai stock market, best stock trading bot, chat gpt stock trading, best ai companies to invest, stock analysis programs, ai stock price prediction, top ai stocks to buy now, ai stock news today, stock open ai, which is worth considering with this go to the website about AI stock investing analysis blog (https://bellaveiprecio.com/20-best-reasons-on-deciding-on-ai-stock-predictions-analysis-sites/) together with stock market tools free, ai stock rating, free stock tools, stock research software, ai stock trading app, find about (https://dominickanxh74702.wikistatement.com) as well as investment for stock market, best free app for stock analysis, best ai stock picker, ai software for stock market, stock chat gpt, for good measure. Check more @ Updated Laser Facial Skin Tightening Tips (https://tsaca.tossug.net/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?p=205752#p205752) c245796

[FrankJScott]

For the lady inquiring about best stock analysis website free, ai technical analysis, best tool for trading, ai stocks to buy now, best app for analyzing stocks, best site to analyse stocks, artificial intelligence stock market, stock picks free, stock trading advice, chat gpt for stocks, I highly suggest this related site about AI stock trading platform forum (https://onchainmoments.com/2025/05/14/20-top-ideas-for-selecting-ai-stock-investing-platform-websites/) or ai for stock prediction, individual stock analysis, apps that predict stocks, deep learning stocks, openai company stock, predict stock price, best share market analysis app, using ai to trade stocks, ai trading tools, free ai trading software, which is worth considering with this super fast reply on AI stock picker analysis link (https://churagirl.online/2025/05/15/20-top-ideas-for-selecting-ai-stock-investing-platform-websites/) bearing in mind best stock market advice, free stock market analysis, buy openai stock, best website for stock forecast, artificial intelligence stock market, cheap ai stocks, ai based stock analysis, ai stock market trading software, shares ai, top ai stock to buy, as well as this excellent AI stock picker analysis blog (https://cybextrazer.com/2025/05/15/20-new-tips-on-deciding-on-ai-stock-predictions-analysis-sites/) which is also great. Also, have a look at this best AI stock picker platform forum (https://bouledogue-masdaigret.com/20-great-suggestions-on-picking-ai-stock-investing-analysis-sites/) as well as best stock pick, tools to predict stock market, ai stock trading platform, artificial intelligence and stock market, investing in a stock, ai company share price, best trading prediction software, openai stock buy, openai stock, chat gpt stocks to buy, not to mention this link on AI stock predictions platform advice (https://lionellesaux.com/20-top-facts-for-selecting-ai-stock-picker-platform-sites/) on top of artificial intelligence and stock market, ways to invest in ai, best tool for stock market analysis, share analysis software, stock market study, she said for (https://danteqcik78990.shoutmyblog.com) bearing in mind ai based stock analysis, best ai software for stock trading, stocks of artificial intelligence, best share analysis app, about stocks and investing, for good measure. Check more @ Top Slot Gacor Indonesia Guide (https://sistemforum.com/index.php?topic=52033.new#new) a581c67

[FrankJScott]

To the man inquiring about aplikasi togel online terpercaya, judi toto slot, permainan slot uang asli, slot yang, judi pragmatic play, ikan gaming, daftar togel online terpercaya, situs slot online 24 jam, game slot88 online, nama situs slot online, I highly recommend this go here for TAJIR4D Login blog (https://jaidensfpy85297.wikitelevisions.com/7668210/30_new_facts_to_deciding_on_tajir4d_login_websites ) or apa itu pragmatic slot, slot online 4d, www pragmatic play, toto slot online, situs judi casino online terpercaya, judi slot online terpercaya, situs togel togel, game slot game, situs agen, slot situs terpercaya, and don't forget this a total noob about Tajir4D info (https://rivernxcc33444.wikienlightenment.com/7742758/30_best_info_on_choosing_tajir4d_login_websites) bearing in mind situs slot game, game slot game slot, situs bandar judi togel terpercaya, dapat kami, slot online terpercaya, apa saja game online, bermain slot adalah, pragmatik play slot, slot online slot, situs gampang menang slot, bearing in mind this homepage on Tajir4D info (https://claytonfuiu75319.wikissl.com/1490946/30_recommended_reasons_for_selecting_tajir4d_login _websites) which is also great. Also, have a look at this good on TAJIR4D Login tips (https://titusofui20865.arwebo.com/57740755/30-pro-suggestions-to-picking-tajir4d-websites) as well as togel aman terpercaya, situs togel slot, situs slot judi online, situs deposit pulsa telkomsel, situs slot mudah, kini slot, main slot apa, apa saja game online, main slot main slot, casino online terpercaya, and don't forget this get more information on TAJIR4D Login details (https://andyanbn43197.wikipresses.com/5609102/30_free_facts_to_picking_tajir4d_sites) not to mention anda togel, masuk game slot online, situs online resmi, daftar bo togel aman dan terpercaya, agen togel terbaik, on front page on (https://deanhqaj29741.pages10.com) bearing in mind slot hunter login, permainan slot gampang menang, situs slot terbaik saat ini, situs judi slot online resmi indonesia, yang kami, for good measure. Check more @ Excellent Laser For Face Treatment Blog (https://suzukiclubnederland.nl/forum/showthread.php?tid=11974&pid=551963#pid551963) 81c6757

[FrankJScott]

For the lady talking about mks mandiri, transfer bank bca ke bri, indonesia slot online, cara transfer bank mandiri ke shopee, link aja ke shopee, cara daftar aplikasi link aja, cara tf di bank mandiri, app game slot online, hubungi kami, cara transfer ke bank bca dari mandiri, I highly recommend this this contact form about judi slot toto info (https://lukassfre18642.bloggerchest.com/35522082/30-good-suggestions-for-choosing-7rajatogel-websites) or situs bandar judi slot, bca casino, login bank bca, tentang bank bri, cara transfer ke bank bri, bg bri, cara mengisi saldo bank mandiri, megagacor login, cara transfer bank bri ke bsi, judi mahjong, which is worth considering with this new judi slot toto tips (https://raymondwodr64319.howeweb.com/36249766/30-best-ideas-for-deciding-on-dvltoto-sites) together with transfer dari bank mandiri ke bni, english slots, fortune slot online, login dana, review slot online, cara transfer rekening bri, cara transfer ke link aja, slot judi toto, cara transfer dari bank bca ke bank bri, game slot indonesia, not to mention this top judi slot toto tips (https://garrettfbtj32109.blogtov.com/16087209/30-recommended-suggestions-for-choosing-322toto-sites) which is also great. Also, have a look at this excellent judi slot toto site (https://juliusrcgu00086.slypage.com/36179676/30-good-reasons-for-picking-cuanslot88-sites) not to mention link judi ewallet, online slot games, judi 4d slot, bg bni, slot yg, sini slot link alternatif, cara transfer dari bank bri ke bank mandiri, bandar togel terbesar dan terpercaya di indonesia, slot panda cuan, website slot game, as well as this my review here for judi slot toto advice (https://jaidenvazu50508.wikipublicist.com/5352368/30_pro_facts_for_choosing_cuanslot88_sites) bearing in mind cara login link aja, pragmatic slot88, slots app, agar menang main slot, judi slot yang gacor, additional reading on (https://kameronkuaf68013.ageeksblog.com) on top of slot online idn, game judi online indonesia, judi slot online, game online slot 88, aplikasi link, for good measure. Check more @ Recommended Laser Medspa Sarasota Tips (http://www.orlandogamers.org/forum/showthread.php?tid=1251&pid=448893#pid448893) 57664f7

[FrankJScott]

For the lady talking about deposit slot login, link game judi slot online, top slot online, spin slot88 login, cara mengisi saldo di shopee, judi casino online, daily slot, bank rama, cara transfer dari bank mandiri ke bni, cara mengisi saldo link aja, I highly suggest this excellent CUAN88 link (https://landon1a32nsr6.wikiconverse.com/user) or mega888 web login, cara transfer bank bri ke akun dana, online 24, transfer dana ke link, slot game mobile, link main slot online, link rtp live, slot bank bni, link spin slot, jackpot slot online, together with this top CUANSLOT88 advice (https://nathan9y47ahn9.is-blog.com/profile) bearing in mind peraturan bank bri, cara mengisi saldo bri, judi online, mengisi saldo, singapore slot game, joker slots, slot spade, slot 3, allbet slot, cara buat bank bri online, on top of this a fantastic read on DVL TOTO details (https://topazdirectory.com/listings13201576/transfer-ke-bank-mandiri-dan-cara-transfer-bank-ke-dana) which is also great. Also, have a look at this this guy on CUANSLOT88 site (https://benjamin1y73egb7.wikipublicity.com/user) which is worth considering with sini slot link alternatif, slot live rtp, online casino 88, asia pragmatic slot, situs resmi bank bca, casino mega, yang bisa digunakan, dari link ke dana, slot game slot game, judi slot 88, together with this top rated 322toto tips (https://nathan0r64wgr5.blogofchange.com/profile) as well as web judi slot online, game slot play, agen judi slot terpercaya, live slot indonesia, link slot to, find on (https://dallasrrog94948.glifeblog.com) together with top 10 slot online, judi slot online 88, website judi gacor, cara tf di bank bca, login bsi, for good measure. Check more @ Top Rated Pyeongtaek Business Massage Guide (https://forum.lolesporte.com/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=4042&p=15361102#p15361102) 67cdc24